Registered: 1042401911 Posts: 4,384
Reply with quote #6
I haven't watched the TED talk but I know with homeopathy the smaller doses are more potent, so he possibly just made it less effective. Also, it works on babies and animals - have they been duped, too? I don't believe there is a lethal dose since homeopathy doesn't work that way. And... it's worked for me and even if it is because I wanted it to, or it was just in my imagination, if it works I'm happy!
Moondance Tintin Chili Beans Martini
Registered: 1388821452 Posts: 1,109
Reply with quote #7
I do not really believe in the supernatural, although funny stuff happens...
I never use homeopathy either. Some people use homeopathy for colds for example. A cold is something that should heal by itself. So if you start using homeopathy after a week of feeling all miserable, and it works, it is probably just your body recovering in a natural way. It is not the homeopathy. I know people who see doctors for a variety of issues. They get treatment, which does not seem to help. Then they resort to homeopathy, and all of sudden, after one day or so, they feel fine again. I am sorry, but I do not believe that sort of stuff. It is your own system recovering from illness in combination with the medication that starts to work. It is not the homeopathy that does it. Unfortunately, sometimes there is no help available. When classic medication will not solve the problem, I doubt alternative methods will work. There are no miracles. A lot of mainstream medication and supplements are also useless for that matter. People just believe it works. My former doctor refused to prescribe certain types of medication because, in his opinion, they are useless. Voltaren gel, bio glucosamin,... I asked my specialist doctor about the latter once, and he did not really answer the question. What does that mean? It means we fool ourselves. __________________ “Dogs are our link to paradise. They don't know evil or jealousy or discontent. To sit with a dog on a hillside on a glorious afternoon is to be back in Eden, where doing nothing was not boring--it was peace.” Milan Kundera. http://borntolisten.com
Pinkie in the Pink Palace
Registered: 1185965531 Posts: 8,239
Reply with quote #8
A "placebo" effect can happen with medicines and patients, which I think maybe Nicky described or maybe the remedies really did work for her. Every one's body is different. I know Western medicine really works and is effective in many cases. However, a diabetes educator impressed on us that helping one's diabetes get better is only 30 percent meds and the rest is diet and exercise.
When I went through a phase a long time ago of taking a lot of various herbs and such in capsule form, including Chinese and Indian types, ironically I discovered I felt better not taking all that. __________________ "more sinned against than sinning"--shall be on my tombstone
"Transpersonal psychology--transcend the self, to abolish and avoid pain...what is the self, anyway?"--Pinkie
"Queen of Pain, I'll Always be Queen of Pain" (laughs)with apologies to Sting
"Yes it's over now, drink your big black cow, and get outa here"--Steely Dan
"I'm just a girl, they think I'm some kind of freak"--Gwen Stefani
"You can beat us with wires, you can beat us with chains;
You can make all your rules but you can't outrun the history train...I seen a glorious day"--Paul Simon